Nanotechnology Now

Heifer International

Wikipedia Affiliate Button


Home > Press > A manufacturing renaissance for America?

Pills are fed through a sorter in a pharmaceutical manufacturing facility. New manufacturing methods in industries such as drug production may be a key to reviving the United States economy.
Pills are fed through a sorter in a pharmaceutical manufacturing facility. New manufacturing methods in industries such as drug production may be a key to reviving the United States economy.

At an MIT forum, experts examine new ways to pursue a good old idea: making things

By Peter Dizikes, MIT News Office

A manufacturing renaissance for America?

Cambridge, MA | Posted on April 1st, 2010

Over the last few decades, the sector of the U.S. economy devoted to manufacturing has lost ground to the services sector. The number of U.S. manufacturing jobs has declined from nearly 20 million in 1979 to about 12 million today. Yet as the recent global recession suggests, services can propel the economy only so far. There is no substitute for making tangible, useful products.

But what form will new kinds of manufacturing take? At an MIT roundtable discussion on Monday titled "The Future of Manufacturing — Advanced Technologies," more than a dozen of the Institute's faculty shared converging ideas about how to reinvigorate America's goods-producing businesses. The roundtable followed a broader campus forum hosted by MIT President Susan Hockfield on March 1, in which faculty members, some of whom also participated in Monday's discussion, offered ideas about how to strengthen America innovation and thus its overall economy. These meetings are part of a larger effort by MIT to contribute the Institute's expertise in emerging technologies and innovation policies to the national effort to revitalize the American economy.

Monday's discussion cast specific issues of manufacturing in the light of broad economic considerations. "To recover from the current economic downturn, it has been estimated that we need to create on the order of 17 million to 20 million new jobs in the coming decade," noted Hockfield in her opening remarks at the event, which was co-sponsored by the Council on Competitiveness, an industry group. "And it's very hard to imagine where those jobs are going to come from unless we seriously get busy reinventing manufacturing." That question should be of great concern to scientists and engineers — 64 percent of whom, Hockfield noted, are employed in the manufacturing sector.

Hockfield also directly addressed the commonly held notion that the United States cannot compete in manufacturing against low-wage countries, citing the success of Japan and Germany, both of which feature trade surpluses and high wages. "I take this as positive proof that building a strong advanced manufacturing sector is not impossible, but very much worth pursuing," Hockfield said. In addition to new business practices and continued strength in education, Hockfield added, "A key hope for progress lies in tapping unprecedented new manufacturing technologies."

Suzanne Berger, a professor of political science and author of How We Compete: What Companies Around the World Are Doing to Make It in Today's Global Economy, asserted that Americans need to be disabused of the notion that manufacturing is "a ‘sunset sector' that should be allowed to sink over the horizon." Increased productivity per worker means the United States still produces 22 percent of the world's goods, Berger noted, a figure that has been roughly constant for 30 years, and which makes the United States the world's top manufacturer. Yet the country "has failed to exploit new opportunities for exporting U.S. goods," she said. "The big problem is not that we can't compete with China on low wages," Berger added, but that the United States has "not developed enough kinds of manufacturing that could generate both high profits and also good jobs."

Material benefits

The roundtable discussion was organized into two consecutive panels, the first of which focused on innovation in materials science. Gerbrand Ceder, a professor in MIT's Department of Materials Science and Engineering (DMSE), outlined how a "Materials Genome Project" can catalogue the properties of known materials and allow designers to better model potential devices, thus accelerating product development. "Clearly there are some things that would be useful to apply in many types of manufacturing," Ceder noted.

Christine Ortiz, an associate professor also in DMSE, described her research group's efforts to study the nano-scale properties of "high-strength, lightweight, penetration-resistant" biological materials. Those properties could then be transferred to synthetic materials, expanding the range of products that can be manufactured through methods such as 3-D printing.

Charles Fine, a professor at the MIT Sloan School of Management, and Richard Roth, of the Engineering Systems Division, both discussed lightweight automobiles as an alternative to traditional vehicles and an area where the United State could re-establish a competitive advantage in manufacturing. "If we take on the hard challenges and succeed, it's not so easy to copy," Fine said. And as Roth noted, "Batteries are extraordinarily expensive," so new materials research leading to lighter cars would lower those costs by reducing vehicle battery size. In turn, that could make electric automobiles more affordable for consumers and a more appealing investment for manufacturers.

But the actual techniques of manufacturing are what most need to be reinvented, asserted Martin Culpepper, an associate professor in MIT's Department of Mechanical Engineering. Over the last 150 years, suggested Culpepper, heavy industry has refined large-scale production techniques effectively, and developed myriad tools suited to its needs. But businesses today must invent equally useful nanotechnology-based manufacturing techniques, he believes, allowing firms to better manipulate matter at the smallest scales in order to produce everything from new industrial materials to cutting-edge medicine.

"We don't have the tools and technologies right now to do a lot of nano-manufacturing in a really practical way," said Culpepper. Moreover, he believes, researchers today who want to commercialize lab discoveries underestimate the difficulties of "integrating the science and the [manufacturing] process … this is not a trivial thing."

Culpepper's own research group aims to create those kinds of small-scale manufacturing tools. Working with one bioscience research institute, he noted, they have been able to roll back the size boundaries of nano-scale DNA arrays, which could make drug production more efficient.

Still, these advances are also restricted, Culpepper said, by the limited number of people with a thorough knowledge of nano-scale manufacturing. "In my lab, it's like an apprenticeship," Culpepper said. "It takes a long time to learn how to do this stuff properly." Universities and their partners, he stated, need to help rectify this problem: "We would like to have more support for training."

Production values

The second panel discussion centered on technology advances for transforming production. Rodney Brooks of MIT's Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory suggested it is increasingly hard for industry to find places that provide low-cost labor, meaning that U.S. firms should instead seek low-cost manufacturing technologies. Specifically, manufacturers who use robotics, Brooks said, have gotten "stuck in what was developed in the 1960s. There's very little integration of sensors and computation with these robots." As a result of this adherence to inflexible technology, Brooks added, "the integration cost of using robots in industry is 5 to 10 times the capital cost of the robots, and only makes sense if you do the same thing again and again."

Bernhardt Trout, a chemical engineering professor and director of the Novartis-MIT Center for Continuous Manufacturing, asserted that the traditional, small-molecule part of the pharmaceuticals industry — firms that make over-the-counter medicines, for instance — invest a "shockingly low" portion of their capital in further product development, instead reaping high profits from existing products, while basic manufacturing technologies have not changed for decades. Trout suggested a streamlined drug-approval process would help motivate industry innovation, but equally claimed the "financialization" of the industry has hurt product development; firms see themselves as "marketing and supply companies." Advances in academic research, Trout said, are thus especially critical if the industry is to move forward.

The rapid spread of manufacturing know-how has had double-edged effects, observed Sanjay Sarma, an associate professor of mechanical engineering. Profitable industries can now be located around the world, while multinational firms build global supply chains to move products in bulk. "The thing that really hurts manufacturing in the U.S. is the flattening effect that comes from economies of scale," Sarma said. In response, Sarma suggested domestic manufacturing can become lucrative with the use of "small-lot logistics," technologies that reduce production and transportation costs and can make many businesses, such as apparel firms, more viable.

However, making new manufacturing environmentally sustainable will be a large challenge, said Timothy Gutowski, also a professor of mechanical engineering. "Here's the problem: Underpriced ecosystem services provide a competitive advantage," said Gutowski, meaning that companies who extract natural resources cheaply still have edges in manufacturing. Cooperation between industry and government — and between governments — will be necessary to put new manufacturing on a sound environmental foundation.

Charles Cooney, a professor of chemical engineering moderating the second panel, concluded that three things are important to improving U.S. manufacturing: an understanding of systems thinking, which can help create new, possibly local and regional forms of manufacture and distribution; a recognition that sound public policy will be a necessary part of new development; and a multi-agency approach to science and technology funding, to improve the odds that more forms of research will move from the lab to the factory.


About MIT
The mission of MIT is to advance knowledge and educate students in science, technology and other areas of scholarship that will best serve the nation and the world in the 21st century — whether the focus is cancer, energy, economics or literature.

For more information, please click here

Copyright © MIT

If you have a comment, please Contact us.

Issuers of news releases, not 7th Wave, Inc. or Nanotechnology Now, are solely responsible for the accuracy of the content.

Delicious Digg Newsvine Google Yahoo Reddit Magnoliacom Furl Facebook

Related News Press

News and information

Strength in numbers: Researchers develop the first-ever quantum device that detects and corrects its own errors March 4th, 2015

New research could lead to more efficient electrical energy storage March 4th, 2015

Energy-generating cloth could replace batteries in wearable devices March 4th, 2015

Arrowhead to Present at 2015 Barclays Global Healthcare Conference March 4th, 2015


Nanotech Discoveries Move from Lab to Marketplace with Lintec Deal: Licensing Partnership Brings Together University Technology, New Richardson-Based Facility Directed by Alumni February 9th, 2015

Secretary Vilsack Announces Partnership to Advance Commercial Potential of Cellulosic Nanomaterial from Wood December 11th, 2013

Cutting Away at the NRC's Research Capability December 6th, 2013

Project aims to mass-produce 'nanopetals' for sensors, batteries October 22nd, 2013


NanoTecNexus Launches New App for Learning About Nanotechnology—STEM Education Project Spearheaded by Interns February 26th, 2015

SUNY Poly CNSE Researchers and Corporate Partners to Present Forty Papers at Globally Recognized Lithography Conference: SUNY Poly CNSE Research Group Awarded Both ‘Best Research Paper’ and ‘Best Research Poster’ at SPIE Advanced Lithography 2015 forum February 25th, 2015

KIT Increases Commitment in Asia: DAAD Funds Two New Projects: Strategic Partnerships with Chinese Universities and Communi-cation Technologies Network February 22nd, 2015

Minus K Technology Announces Its 2015 Vibration Isolator Educational Giveaway to U.S. Colleges and Universities February 18th, 2015


Patent for the Novel Cancer Therapies – Ceramide Nanoliposomes March 4th, 2015

Arrowhead to Present at 2015 Barclays Global Healthcare Conference March 4th, 2015

Democratizing synthetic biology: New method makes research cheaper, faster, and more accessible March 3rd, 2015

Pens filled with high-tech inks for do-it-yourself sensors March 3rd, 2015


The taming of magnetic vortices: Unified theory for skyrmion-materials March 3rd, 2015

Breakthrough in OLED technology March 2nd, 2015

Moving molecule writes letters: Caging of molecules allows investigation of equilibrium thermodynamics February 27th, 2015

Graphene shows potential as novel anti-cancer therapeutic strategy: University of Manchester scientists have used graphene to target and neutralise cancer stem cells while not harming other cells February 26th, 2015


Experiment and theory unite at last in debate over microbial nanowires: New model and experiments settle debate over metallic-like conductivity of microbial nanowires in bacterium March 4th, 2015

Magnetic vortices in nanodisks reveal information: Researchers from Dresden and Jülich use microwaves to read out information from smallest storage devices March 4th, 2015

CiQUS researchers obtain high-quality perovskites over large areas by a chemical method March 4th, 2015

Arrowhead to Present at 2015 Barclays Global Healthcare Conference March 4th, 2015


Keysight Technologies Shifts to Direct Sales of High-Performance Products in North America March 3rd, 2015

Forbidden quantum leaps possible with high-res spectroscopy March 2nd, 2015

International research partnership tricks the light fantastic March 2nd, 2015

Important step towards quantum computing: Metals at atomic scale March 2nd, 2015


Heightened Efficiency in Purification of Wastewater Using Nanomembranes March 3rd, 2015

Novel Method to Determine Optical Purity of Drug Components March 1st, 2015

In quest for better lithium-air batteries, chemists boost carbon's stability: Nanoparticle coatings improve stability, cyclability of '3DOm' carbon February 25th, 2015

Purification of Industrial Wastewater Using Visible-Light Sensitive Photocatalysts February 24th, 2015


Arrowhead to Present at 2015 Barclays Global Healthcare Conference March 4th, 2015

Cambrios and Heraeus Jointly Create New, High-Conductivity Transparent Conductors: Two Companies' Combined Products Dramatically Extend Flexible Substrate Capabilities for Next-Generation Mass-Market Technology Products March 3rd, 2015

International research partnership tricks the light fantastic March 2nd, 2015

UC research partnership explores how to best harness solar power March 2nd, 2015


Experiment and theory unite at last in debate over microbial nanowires: New model and experiments settle debate over metallic-like conductivity of microbial nanowires in bacterium March 4th, 2015

Untangling DNA with a droplet of water, a pipet and a polymer: With the 'rolling droplet technique,' a DNA-injected water droplet rolls like a ball over a platelet, sticking the DNA to the plate surface February 27th, 2015

Bacteria network for food: Bacteria connect to each other and exchange nutrients February 23rd, 2015

Building tailor-made DNA nanotubes step by step: New, block-by-block assembly method could pave way for applications in opto-electronics, drug delivery February 23rd, 2015

The latest news from around the world, FREE

  Premium Products
Only the news you want to read!
 Learn More
University Technology Transfer & Patents
 Learn More
Full-service, expert consulting
 Learn More

Nanotechnology Now Featured Books


The Hunger Project

© Copyright 1999-2015 7th Wave, Inc. All Rights Reserved PRIVACY POLICY :: CONTACT US :: STATS :: SITE MAP :: ADVERTISE