Nanotechnology Now

Our NanoNews Digest Sponsors

Heifer International

Wikipedia Affiliate Button

Home > Press > In Industrial Manufacturing, Efficiency Falls as Technology Advances

Advanced technologies are less efficient in their use of energy and materials per kilogram of output.

Credit:  2009 Jupiter Images Corporation; USC BMES ERC
Advanced technologies are less efficient in their use of energy and materials per kilogram of output.

Credit: 2009 Jupiter Images Corporation; USC BMES ERC

Abstract:
A comprehensive study of old and new manufacturing processes, from machining metal to making carbon nanofibers, shows that the more advanced technologies are less efficient in their use of energy and materials per kilogram of output

In Industrial Manufacturing, Efficiency Falls as Technology Advances

Arlington, VA | Posted on May 4th, 2009

A century ago, industrial manufacturing was dominated by large-scale, energy-hungry processes such as smelting ores and machining metals. Today, the industrial landscape features an array of novel techniques operating on much smaller scales, making computer chips, carbon nanofibers, and other sophisticated products. That evolution toward more technologically advanced manufacturing has happened, a new study shows, at the cost of a sharp decrease in efficiency. The most hi-tech processes can take as much as a million times more energy and materials to make a given quantity of finished product than traditional industrial methods--a trend that may hinder efforts to build a more energy-conscious industrial economy using cutting-edge materials and technology.

Any manufacturing process uses energy to transform starting materials into a desired product. But some fraction of the starting materials will generally go to waste, and energy is not always used as efficiently as it might be. To better understand these losses, Timothy Gutowski of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in Cambridge, Mass., and his colleagues have developed a framework, based on the laws of thermodynamics, that keeps track of both the energetic, as well as the physical or chemical, transformations of materials as they pass through the steps of an industrial process.

The researchers surveyed 20 manufacturing techniques. Traditional processes included melting and casting metal, grinding and machining, and injection molding of plastics, along with more recent innovations such as the use of lasers and water jets to shape materials. Rounding out the list of techniques were the wide range of processes used in the microelectronics sector, such as chemical vapor deposition and sputtering, as well as carbon nanofiber production.

With the exception of the methods that involved melting metal, the overall power requirements for each process were surprisingly similar, ranging from about 5 to 50 kilowatts of electricity. On the other hand, the amounts of material processed varied enormously, ranging from hundreds of kilograms per hour or more for the older processes to just a few milligrams per hour for two of the most novel techniques. A striking trend emerged: as processes become more technologically sophisticated, they tend to manipulate smaller and smaller quantities of material at slower rates, but since power consumption per process has stayed about the same, the amount of energy needed to generate a given quantity of finished product has been growing fast.

An inefficient process operating on a tiny amount of material may not be very important when set against the entirety of industrial energy use, Gutowski and his colleagues observe. They point out, however, that the world now produces more than 20,000 tons of electronics-grade silicon per year, consuming about fifty billion kilowatt-hours of electricity in the process. Production of carbon fibers, which are often proposed for large scale applications, is in the same ballpark in terms of energy used per kilogram of product. Both industries involve processes that fall in the middle and lower range of efficiencies found by the MIT researchers, so that the lack of attention to making better use of energy could have significant consequences.

Modern industrial techniques often require elaborate materials and procedures that exact energetic and material costs but don't get directly incorporated into the product. For example, highly reactive gases may be used to clean production equipment for silicon chips in preparation for other steps, and those gases may have to be chemically treated after use for safety or pollution-control reasons. These ancillary but essential elements of a hi-tech manufacturing process can reduce enormously its "degree of perfection"--the ratio of the thermodynamic value of the product to the thermodynamic value of everything that was needed to make it. The more ideal a process, the closer that ratio will be to one. In reality, processes can vary significantly in their degree of perfection. For example, the MIT team calculated that an electric furnace that melts scrap and other iron to produce a refined metal output can have a degree of perfection of 0.79. By contrast, a chemical vapor deposition method used by the semiconductor industry to produce thin layers of silicon dioxide can have a degree of perfection of not quite four millionths.

In designing processes that turn expensive materials into small quantities of hi-tech products, manufacturers have focused their attention on a variety of issues such as size and quality, but "haven't had strong incentives to reduce energy consumption," Gutowski says. But that may be changing. Manufacturers of solar panels, for example, are well aware of the energy-intensive nature of the processes they use, and figure it into estimates of the pay-back time--in energy as well as money--of the devices they make. To be truly green, in other words, a solar panel must deliver substantially more energy over its lifetime than was consumed in creating it.

That kind of thinking hasn't yet taken hold in other areas, such as nanomaterials, Gutowski adds, where the energy costs of manufacturing are not widely known. As more applications of such materials gain attention, especially in the context of "green" technology, "there will have to be a serious conversation about dealing with energy costs." By providing a comprehensive analytical model that can account for both material and energy use in industrial manufacturing, the MIT study provides the language in which that conversation can be conducted.
-- David Lindley

####

For more information, please click here

Contacts:
The National Science Foundation
4201 Wilson Boulevard
Arlington, Virginia 22230, USA
Tel: (703) 292-5111
FIRS: (800) 877-8339
TDD: (800) 281-8749

Copyright © National Science Foundation

If you have a comment, please Contact us.

Issuers of news releases, not 7th Wave, Inc. or Nanotechnology Now, are solely responsible for the accuracy of the content.

Bookmark:
Delicious Digg Newsvine Google Yahoo Reddit Magnoliacom Furl Facebook

Related News Press

News and information

Oxford Instruments announces Dr Kate Ross as winner of the 2018 Lee Osheroff Richardson Science Prize for North and South America February 20th, 2018

Computers aid discovery of new, inexpensive material to make LEDs with high color quality February 20th, 2018

Unconventional superconductor may be used to create quantum computers of the future: They have probably succeeded in creating a topological superconductor February 19th, 2018

Photonic chip guides single photons, even when there are bends in the road February 16th, 2018

Announcements

Oxford Instruments announces Dr Kate Ross as winner of the 2018 Lee Osheroff Richardson Science Prize for North and South America February 20th, 2018

Computers aid discovery of new, inexpensive material to make LEDs with high color quality February 20th, 2018

Unconventional superconductor may be used to create quantum computers of the future: They have probably succeeded in creating a topological superconductor February 19th, 2018

Photonic chip guides single photons, even when there are bends in the road February 16th, 2018

Interviews/Book Reviews/Essays/Reports/Podcasts/Journals/White papers

Computers aid discovery of new, inexpensive material to make LEDs with high color quality February 20th, 2018

Photonic chip guides single photons, even when there are bends in the road February 16th, 2018

'Living bandages': NUST MISIS scientists develop biocompatible anti-burn nanofibers February 15th, 2018

Rutgers-Led Innovation Could Spur Faster, Cheaper, Nano-Based Manufacturing: Scalable and cost-effective manufacturing of thin film devices February 14th, 2018

Industrial

Ultra-efficient removal of carbon monoxide using gold nanoparticles on a molecular support: New method and mechanism for state-of-the-art gas purification February 9th, 2018

A simple new approach to plastic solar cells: Osaka University researchers intelligently design new highly efficient organic solar cells based on amorphous electronic materials with potential for easy printing January 28th, 2018

Nature paper by Schlumberger researchers used photothermal based nanoscale IR spectroscopy to analyze heterogeneous process of petroleum generation January 23rd, 2018

New filters could enable manufacturers to perform highly-selective chemical separation January 23rd, 2018

NanoNews-Digest
The latest news from around the world, FREE



  Premium Products
NanoNews-Custom
Only the news you want to read!
 Learn More
NanoStrategies
Full-service, expert consulting
 Learn More











ASP
Nanotechnology Now Featured Books




NNN

The Hunger Project