Home > Press > ASU colleges collaborate on ethics project
A transdisciplinary team of faculty members and students at ASU has begun a research project to address the growing lag between emerging technologies, and the policies and ethics that govern them, and to recommend solutions for improving the timeliness and flexibility of these regulatory processes.
ASU colleges collaborate on ethics project
Tempe, AZ | Posted on November 14th, 2007
The group received an $80,000 grant from the Joan and David Lincoln Center for Applied Ethics at ASU for the project, titled "Addressing the Growing Gap Between Rapidly Emerging Technologies and Ethical, Legal and Policy Capabilities." The project will be led by:
• Gary Marchant, Lincoln Professor of Emerging Technologies, Law & Ethics in the Sandra Day O'Connor College of Law, and executive director of the college's Center for the Study of Law, Science, & Technology.
• Braden Allenby, Lincoln Professor of Engineering and Ethics in the Ira A. Fulton School of Engineering.
• Joseph Herkert, Lincoln Associate Professor of Ethics and Technology in the School of Applied Arts and Sciences.
"This project fits perfectly with these three Lincoln professors, with the center and with the Lincoln family, which has always been involved in technology," says Peter French, director of the Lincoln Center. "What we're looking for here is to expose the problem, that various technologies in so many different areas have advanced way past not only what the law, but what ethics as well, can track. And we need to look at how to keep pace."
Marchant says the project will tackle an exciting intellectual issue: how to get the law and ethics to move more quickly.
"We see this as a big project for the next two to three years at the law school and the university," he says. "Science and technology are moving faster than ever before, but the pace of rule-making and policy-making is clearly slowing down."
Marchant cites numerous examples of antiquated laws, unregulated new technologies in the areas of genetics and biotechnology, nanotechnology, cognitive sciences and information and enhancement technologies, and agencies bogged down in public-hearing methods that haven't kept up with the times.
For example, Marchant says, adoption of a single regulation in the Occupational Safety and Health Administration often takes eight or more years, and the Clean Water Act of 1972 doesn't regulate runoff, which is among the top sources of water pollution today.
A dramatic example of the law lagging far behind technology can be found at the Federal Communications Commission, he says. Despite the fact that an estimated 250 million Americans use cell phones, the FCC claims it isn't ready to regulate how cell phone service providers use the private information of its users. And there's virtually no regulation of Radio-Frequency Identification, which can be used to track a product, animal or person.
"With a lot of technology being developed today, the whole idea is to know who you are and where you are," says Herkert, referring to a range of new communication and tracking technologies now entering the market. "What does privacy mean in that context? Is there such a thing?"
The gap between science and policy development also puts businesses and their investors at a disadvantage, depriving the certainty and predictability they need to plan and innovate, and posing a growing threat to the future of our economy and health, the researchers say.
"In my discussions with people, I have been amazed at how unaware most are of how rapidly technology is advancing, and its implications for our lives," Allenby says. "In light of accelerating technological evolution, the need for ethical and responsive legal structures is important not just to support our quality of life, but as an increasingly critical matter of national competitiveness."
The project calls for the researchers to first establish specific problems in the pacing of technology, science and the law, by developing case studies on the speed of technology development. They then will develop models that may enable policy-makers, courts and regulators to respond more quickly.
"And it's not just the speed of innovation, it's the quality of the technology itself," Herkert says. "Nanotechnology is a great example. We're dealing with materials with novel properties that we don't have an experience base with. The idea of regulating it by historic examples doesn't necessarily hold in this case."
A cluster of law students has begun working in five areas - genetic testing and human enhancement, brain scanning, surveillance technologies, nanotechnology and environmental advancements - and studying how these are regulated by agencies, legislatures and the courts.
Next fall, a workshop will be held at ASU that will involve about 20 leading scholars, policy-makers and others who will discuss the issue of pacing ethics and law with rapidly developing technologies and hammer out the proposed solutions. These ideas will be presented and discussed at the workshop at ASU in October 2008, then published as a book and a Web site, for use by policy-makers, regulators, journalists, industry experts, public interest groups, scholars and members of the public.
"We're thinking of this two to three years as a seeding project that will allow the team to proceed to a more significant grant to carry the project to the next level," French says.
The Joan and David Lincoln Center for Applied Ethics, located online at http://www.asu.edu/clas/lincolncenter , is a unique resource that supports ethics and encourages the practice of ethical behavior. The center is dedicated to emphasizing the essential role that morals and values play in the achievements of individuals and organizations. The center's goal is to create a university and community ethical culture. It will do so by sponsoring an array of activities ranging from course development to conferences on ethics issues that occur in specific fields and professions, as well as those of pressing importance in the community at large.
About Arizona State University
A comprehensive public metropolitan research university enrolling more than 60,000 undergraduate, graduate, and professional students on four campuses, ASU is a federation of unique colleges, schools, departments, and research institutes that comprise close-knit but diverse academic communities that are international in scope. ASU champions intellectual and cultural diversity, and welcomes students from all 50 states and more than one hundred nations across the globe.
For more information, please click here
ASU Media Relations
PO Box 871803
Tempe, AZ 85287-1803
Copyright © Arizona State University
If you have a comment, please Contact
Issuers of news releases, not 7th Wave, Inc. or Nanotechnology Now, are solely responsible for the accuracy of the content.
PETA science consortium experts to present at international nanotechology workshop: PETA International Science Consortium, Ltd., Is a Sponsor of Nano Risk Analysis II September 12th, 2014
PETA science consortium to present hazard testing strategy at nanotoxicology meeting: High tech field ripe for use of sophisticated non-animal testing strategies April 22nd, 2014
Scientists disagree on responsible research April 8th, 2014
Caltech Researchers Create Light-Bending Silicon Chip: Bending the Light with a Tiny Chip March 10th, 2014
Renishaw receives Queen's Award for spectroscopy developments November 25th, 2014
JPK reports on the use of AFM and the CellHesion module to study plant cells at the University of Queensland November 25th, 2014
Vegetable oil ingredient key to destroying gastric disease bacteria: In mice, therapeutic nanoparticles dampen H. pylori bacteria and inflammation that lead to ulcers and gastric cancer November 25th, 2014
Research yields material made of single-atom layers that snap together like Legos November 25th, 2014
New research project supports internationalisation in nano-research: Launch of new “Baltic Sea Network” November 22nd, 2014
UO-industry collaboration points to improved nanomaterials: University of Oregon microscope puts spotlight on the surface structure of quantum dots for designing new solar devices November 20th, 2014
A novel method for identifying the body’s ‘noisiest’ networks November 19th, 2014
Field-emission plug-and-play solution for microwave electron guns: To simplify the electron emission mechanism involved in microwave electron guns, a team of researchers has created and demonstrated a field-emission plug-and-play solution based on ultrananocrystalline diamond November 18th, 2014